Beloved DIY Space Pet Rescue Says Goodbye

by | Jun 28, 2022 | Features | 1 comment

The final night at Pet Rescue (photo by Jeanette D. Moses)


I’m not crying, YOU’RE crying! Grief manifests itself in different ways, and the loss of our beloved Brooklyn DIY space, Pet Rescue, which just closed its doors after a legendary 10 year run has me oozing all the feels. DIY spaces come and go. Often, many shutter before we get a chance to check them out, and if one lasts more than a few years even it’s a miracle. How Pet Rescue managed to last a full decade without even the cops being called once is beyond comprehension. The place may as well be a thousand year old goddamn unicorn.


If you’ve ever been to Pet Rescue’s loft space—tucked behind 2 large truck beds on the loading docks at 346 Morgan Ave— you understand. And if you haven’t, I’m truly sorry. Brian LaRue (Safe Houses FKA Shelter Dogs) found the place on Craigslist in 2012, and over the next 10 years, hundreds upon hundreds of the best local musicians, as well as countless bands touring thru NYC, would find a safe, friendly, and inclusive place to connect (and sometimes crash) with the other weirdos in the Brooklyn community. Barely held together by found lumber, duct tape, and old windows from Brian’s parents’ house—and definitely not legally zoned for residential use—it felt like home every single night and I fucking loved it.


Exterior of Pet Rescue

Exterior of Pet Rescue

Exterior of Pet Rescue (photos by Sam Sumpter)


But LaRue actually lived there for the first 6 years and change, as did PJ Levine (La Di Das, Significant Others) who took over the place and moved in from 2019 until he was evicted last week. It was nothing short of a very carefully calculated decision by LaRue as to who would take over Pet Rescue upon his departure, as the integrity of stewardship of the space was paramount in passing the torch. PJ didn’t miss a beat fostering and continuing the ethos of Pet Rescue as his own, navigating through the darkest times of the pandemic which befell him shortly after being handed the keys.


Pet Rescue

Brian LaRue and PJ Levine (photo by Jon Daily)


So obviously Pet Rescue wasn’t all sunshine, bubblegum, candy and roses. Running a DIY venue—especially in Brooklyn—is HARD. There was the constant and looming threat of being shut down, the poorly ventilated sweltering summers and freezing winters. Not to mention hosting shows in your single room not-exactly-legal apartment in itself can be a huge pain in the ass. So it’s really not at all surprising that LaRue never intended to start a venue. He just wanted to throw parties and have a place that his and his friends’ bands could play. Steve Perry (The Planes) recently said in the final weeks “It’s not a cultural landmark, and was never trying to be. It’s just a good fucking house party, with loud fucking bands, and cheap fucking beer. And that’s why I think I love it so much.”


While it was a high honor that my band, Nihiloceros, got to return and play the penultimate show a week before the doors closed for good, it was LaRue’s band (now Safe Houses) who fittingly played the final bash along with The Rizzos, The Burning Sun (from Burlington VT), Significant Others (Levine’s band), and Reclining Nude. Brian beautifully and quite perfectly summed up the spirit of the place in a spontaneous off the cuff toast mid-set that commanded the complete attention of every soul in the room. “It was you guys that saw more in this place,” LaRue said. “And you taught each other how to treat each other.” That’s really always been the heart of Pet Rescue; people gathering and making space and working together to help one another out and have a good time. 


Interior of Pet Rescue

Interior of Pet Rescue (photo by Sam Sumpter)


Pet Rescue was really a testament to embracing the weird curves life puts in your path; the joyful surprises and happy accidents. Jon Daily (The Black Black, Kissed by an Animal, bandNada) added “Brian nailed it in his toast. Pet Rescue is about saying yes to things slightly outside of your comfort zone and following the opportunities that arise…and rock and roll. It’s also about rock and roll.”


Pet Rescue

Keep the door closed! (photo by Mike Borchardt)


Pet Rescue was really a special place, built and run by special people who put in a lot of thankless work and lived the unseen stresses and hassles for years just to give us this place to exist and play. And we all breathed life into that old cozy loft week after week, month after month, year after year for 10 fucking years. That’s nothing short of amazing. And that’s also why it’s not really ever gone. It’s the people who make up Pet Rescue and while it’ll be sad to know the wood and the plaster has all been torn down and gutted, its soul will never die.


It lives on in places like East Williamsburg Econolodge, Catfarm and Rubulad. Jon Daily (who runs Econolodge) called the final show “a perfect finale for Pet Rescue—a celebration, not a funeral.” The very final set at Pet Rescue fittingly began well after midnight technically into the next morning of the next day. Justin Ferraro, bassist of The Rizzos, leaning into the microphone saying (now years after their infamous show there where someone literally tore out all the plumbing) “We are the Rizzos and we’re here to kill Pet Rescue…again.”


Video by Nara’s Room


Scroll down for pics of the final Pet Rescue show (photos by Jeanette D. Moses)




Significant Others performing



The Rizzos performing

The Rizzos performing

The Rizzos performing

The Rizzos performing


Help support independent journalism, donate to FTA